The Patient Brokering Act and Addiction Treatment

anti kickbackBy: Jeff CohenFlorida Board Certified Healthcare Lawyer 

Followers of the addiction treatment industry should be on high alert after the arrest of Christopher Hutson of Whole Life Recovery.  The arrest marks the first arrest of any industry provider utilizing the state Patient Brokering Act (PBA).  Relying solely on the allegations, the arrest is based on a business relationship between the provider and sober homes.  Discussion in the “case management agreement” referred to in the arrest affidavit circles around some key allegations that include or imply (1) payment for patient referral, and (2) services by sober homes paid for by Whole Life which were not actually performed.

Serious industry providers absolutely MUST be well educated by lawyers who have years’ experience dealing daily with issues that include the federal Anti-Kickback Statute (and safe harbors), the bona fide employee exception to the AKS, the PBA and how insurers and regulators (inside Florida and outside Florida) interpret and apply such laws.  Any contract (like the sort of agreement referred to in the arrest warrant affidavit) that isn’t preceded by careful client education about the laws, the options and risks of each option is just reckless.  Clients who are well educated will understand things like—

  1. “Making someone a W-2” doesn’t mean compliance;
  2. The term “bona fide” means active direction, supervision and control;
  3. “Papering things up right” doesn’t mean compliance;
  4. FMV means “fair market value”;
  5. An externally determined FMV can be meaningful (depending on what goes into it), but an internally performed FMV is of questionable value in this space;
  6. PSA compliance has nothing at all to do with prostate health;
  7. Complying with applicable law and doing things in a way that reduces risks associated with payers and regulators is not the same thing; and
  8. There’s a huge difference between structural and operational compliance, and both are absolutely necessary.

4 thoughts on “The Patient Brokering Act and Addiction Treatment

  1. Yeah so tell us how to do it right instead of vague proclamations . I know it’s hard to believe but some of us really want to do it right and help our clients. And make money. Show us the right way obviously the case management agreement we paid for was a waste of money.

  2. Pingback: SHOOT, READY, AIM: Palm Beach County’s Blind Shot at the Addiction Treatment Industry | Florida Healthcare Law Firm Blog

  3. Pingback: Florida Lawmakers On the Attack Re Marketing in the Substance Abuse Industry | Florida Healthcare Law Firm Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s